First introduced in 1810, the Old Overholt rye wkiskey remains to this day one of America’s most appreciated whiskey brands.

Today, we’re going to provide you with a comprehensive Old Overholt review, which includes details about the flavor, price, and tasting notes of this whiskey, as well as other interesting and important aspects you should keep in mind before purchasing a bottle of Old Overholt.

Let’s see why this whiskey is one that people still drink nowadays.

Don’t Have Cash For Decent Rye Whiskey? You will LOVE these brands

Old Overholt Review

General Information

Named after Abraham Overholt, the man who founded the Overholt distillery at the beginning of the 1800s, this rye whiskey became extremely popular during the Prohibition, when it received a medicinal license. Even though nowadays, the brand’s headquarters have moved and the company is owned by Beam, the product remains the same woody and tannic whiskey that was the favorite of many famous people, such as Abraham Lincoln, John F. Kennedy, or Ulysses S. Grant.

Tasting Notes


This is where the spiciness of this whiskey comes into play. The spiciness is accompanied by hints of course grains, lemon pepper, and soft woodiness. Interestingly enough, the spiciness is also subverted by a strange sweetness that runs just alongside it. This creates a unique juxtaposition of completely different flavors and makes the Old Overholt whiskey an interesting choice.


The first thing you sense when tasting this whiskey is the fact that it has a thick and sweet scent, somewhat similar to caramel frosting. This scent is followed by notes of green apple, cinnamon, and a very interesting flavor of pie crust made of graham crackers. Everything is topped off with a bit of rye spice and iodine, forming a really pleasurable bouquet. It’s also worth mentioning that the rye notes are quite light.


The finish of the Old Overholt rye whiskey takes you back to that graham cracker flavor, as well as to the green apples one. The finish is medium and it fades to a lovely sugared oak flavor.

Feel, Appearance, Balance, and Body

No Old Overholt rye whiskey review would be complete without some information regarding the drink’s body, balance, feel, and appearance. When it comes to appearance, the whiskey has a beautiful golden honey color. It’s well-balanced, specifically because it’s smooth and it has a light body. This also means it’s not that complex, but that doesn’t take away from its taste.

Old Overholt Price

In terms of price, the Old Overholt rye whiskey, being an American standard, is available for a relatively cheap price. While most of the prices for a bottle of 1 liter revolve around $20, you can also pay as little as $13 for a 750ml bottle, depending on where you buy it from. This makes the Old Overholt whiskey one of the most affordable rye whiskeys you can find on the market.

Final Verdict

If you’re looking for an exquisite yet affordable rye whiskey to use for cocktails, the Old Overholt rye whiskey is one of the best options you have. Its longevity proves it’s an American classic, and its spicy flavor illustrates the reasons why. We give it 4 1/2 stars out of 5.

We hope this Old Overholt review managed to inform you of the main details you should be aware of before buying it.

Have you sampled this rye whiskey before? Let us know what you thought of it in the comments below!

Image Source: GearPatrol.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This
%d bloggers like this: