The only way to find the best rye whiskey around is to sample various rye whiskey brands and see which one suits your taste.
Luckily, we whiskey aficionados have a lot of rye whiskey brands to choose from. Naturally, this makes for some very interesting competition.
In today’s guide, we’ll talk about 9 of the best rye whiskey brands on the market, from the most affordable one to the most expensive one, telling you what makes them so special and why you should consider buying each of them.
9 Best Rye Whiskey Brands to Check Out
1. Old Overholt Straight Rye
The oldest rye whiskey in America, Old Overholt is also one of the cheapest options you have.
You could literally only pay $20 for a 1-liter bottle. And, the drink you get is definitely worth the money.
This is a tough and straightforward whiskey, which doesn’t take away from its smoothness. Its finish is particularly attractive due to it’s calm and fruity.
If you’re looking for a cheap but high-quality rye whiskey, Old Overholt is definitely the way to go. We highly recommend you check out our comprehensive guide on this Rye Whiskey.
2. Rittenhouse Rye
For people who love sweet tasting rye whiskeys, Rittenhouse rye whiskey is a perfect choice.
Even the smell has the capacity to remind you of brown sugar, dark caramel, and buttercream.
The taste pulls all of these flavors even closer together, making this whiskey one of the tastiest ones around. The price is also extremely affordable. A bottle of Rittenhouse rye whiskey costs about $24.
You can drink this whiskey neat or use it for all sorts of rye whiskey cocktails.
3. Knob Creek Straight Rye
While this straight rye whiskey isn’t Knob Creek’s most representative drink (their bourbon is), this is still a rye whiskey variety you should try if you’re interested in sampling some of the best rye whiskeys you can find.
This whiskey isn’t as spicy as other rye whiskeys, but it is spicier than their bourbon, which gives it just the right kick. However, overall, the whiskey is sweet and also earthy, perfect for nature lovers.
A bottle of Knob Creek Straight Rye costs about $32.
4. Wild Turkey 101 Rye
The reason we fit Wild Turkey 101 Rye here is due to its varying prices.
You can pay $35 for one, but you can also pay as much as $45, depending on where you buy it from.
Out of all the rye whiskeys on today’s list, this is one of the spiciest ones, which makes it worthy of being a rye whiskey. Many people still swear by it to this day, due to its sharp taste and its honey and apple aftertaste, which tempers its spiciness.
One thing you should know is that Wild Turkey 101 Rye is sometimes difficult to find. You might have to look around for a bit if you really want to sample it.
5. Bulleit Rye
This award-winning rye whiskey came about as a request from people who were already fans of Bulleit’s other types of spirits.
Luckily, it didn’t fail to meet their expectations.
This rye whiskey is aged in white oak barrels for 4 to 7 years. Its flavors are also something to be looking forward to when tasting it. The effect upon the nose is that of a caramel and cherry feel, while on the palate, the whiskey is fruity, with accents of vanilla and toffee.
The price of a Bulleit Rye whiskey bottle is of $41.
6. Journeyman Distillery Last Feather Organic Rye
A bit more expensive than Bulleit rye whiskey ($48 a bottle), the Journeyman Distillery Last Feather Rye is a true rustic delight bottled for the pleasure of whiskey connoisseurs.
It has a nutty flavor with hints of cinnamon, pine, pipe tobacco, smoke, beer, oak, and cream.
While you could mix this whiskey for cocktails, it would be a pity to take any of its flavors away. That’s why we recommend drinking it neat.
7. Pikesville 110 Proof Straight Rye
Another more expensive rye whiskey option, the Pikesville 110 Proof Rye can still be considered a bargain.
Why? Because of its incredibly velvety taste that is typical of the Maryland style. It managed to come out second in Jim Murray’s Whiskey Bible of 2016, which is one of the most comprehensive guides for whiskey lovers out there.
This is definitely an accomplishment that alone makes this whiskey worth buying.
A bottle costs about $50. You should expect it to contain 51% rye, 10% malted barley, and 39% corn.
8. Colonel E.H. Taylor, Jr. Straight Rye
This rye whiskey from Colonel E.H. Taylor is one that you should really take the time to savor and appreciate.
Its complexity and different flavors make it one of the most exquisite rye whiskeys on today’s list.
While it’s true that the $70 for a bottle pushes the boundaries of ‘budget whisky’, its quality won’t disappoint you.
The nose tasting notes are of spices and cinnamon. On the palate, you’ll feel fruity and sugary notes that take away some of the original spicinesses. Then, the finish leaves you with aftershocks of cocoa, gardenia, and oak.
9. Dark Horse Distillery “Reunion” Rye
Finishing off today’s list of some of the best rye whiskey varieties on the market is a whiskey truly worthy of its name.
Dark Horse has come up with a rye whiskey that you need only open to convince yourself that you’ll be tasting a truly amazing drink. The initial smell is that of clove and cinnamon, while the blend in itself is rough and satisfying.
A bottle of Dark Horse Distillery “Reunion” Rye costs about $70 as well.
Rye whiskey is definitely not a drink for everybody, especially not particularly spicy brands.
Luckily, not all brands are spicy.
Moreover, there are so many rye whiskey brands that you can easily come across nowadays, that it’s not at all difficult to find your favorite one. We hope today’s guide has managed to provide you with at least one rye whiskey option to suit your taste, whether you like stronger drinks or sweeter and fruitier ones.
Don’t forget to let us know which ones you’ve sampled and what you thought of them in the comments down below. Did you find this post useful? Make sure you share it with friends on Facebook or Twitter.